Plan Information
Why PrimeTime Health Plan?

Rated Five Stars by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) for 2024

For three years in a row, PrimeTime Health Plan has received CMS’s highest rating of five stars. Every year, Medicare rates plans and the number of the stars represents how well a plan performs based on member feedback and data from members, doctors and hospitals. A 5-star rating is considered excellent.

Because of our five-star rating, you don’t have to wait until open enrollment to experience our five-star plan. You can enroll in a PrimeTime Health Plan Medicare Advantage Plan between December 8th – November 30th!

Learn more about our five-star rating




Recognized as One of the BEST Medicare Advantage Plans in Ohio

gold badge with blue ribbon with us news world report 2023 medicare advantage best insurance companiesU.S. News and World Report analyzed plans in each state and rated PrimeTime Health Plan as one of the best Medicare Advantage plans in the state. This is the seventh time in eight years that we have received this honor. 






Serving Residents of Northeast Ohio

Since 1997, more than 14,000 Medicare-eligible individuals have enrolled with PrimeTime Health Plan. We provide Northeast Ohio residents with quality coverage and care through affordable Medicare Advantage, also known as Part C, plans. Original Medicare does not offer the additional benefits, like prescription drug coverage (Part D) or dental and vision, that Medicare Advantage plans can supply.

PrimeTime Health Plan serves Carroll, Columbiana, Harrison, Holmes, Mahoning, Medina, Portage, Stark, Summit, Tuscarawas and Wayne counties in Northeast Ohio. 


Learn more about our locally-owned Medicare Advantage plans




Experience the Benefits of PrimeTime Health Plan

Benefits vary based on the plan

blue icon circle with tooth and badge checkmarkDental Coverage Included

Our plans include an allowance for dental care. Up to $1,150 allowance, dependent on plan, to be used towards dental care. Choose your own dental provider!


blue icon circle with Rx and badge checkmarkPart D Prescription Drug Coverage

Over 170 preferred generic medications are available for $0 copay and additional gap coverage for tier one and two medications. (Not included on Basic MA Only plan.)


blue icon circle with over the count medicine and badge checkmarkOver-the-Counter (OTC) Allowance 

Up to $300 annual allowance for OTC health-related items through Optum Personal Care. Shop with a convenient debit card.



blue icon circle with eye chart and badge checkmarkVision Coverage and Eyeware Allowance

Our plans include a $0 copay for routine exams and an allowance. Up to $300 allowance towards glasses and contacts available.



blue icon circle with zero and badge checkmark$0 Monthly Premium

Plans start as low as a $0 monthly premium with Part D coverage!



Learn more about the benefits available with each plan




Expansive Network of Providers and Hospitals

illustrated doctor in a magnifying glassYour choice of over 16,000 providers and more than 35 hospitals in-network, including University Hospitals and Cleveland Clinic.

Find an in-network physician, specialist, or facility






AultmanNow Telehealth

aultmannow blue green logoAvailable on Basic-MA, Aultimate, Classic and Plus plans,  AultmanNow is a fast, easy, and cost-effective telehealth service. With AultmanNow, you can see a provider through video visits anytime on your smartphone, tablet, or computer. It's easy to use, private, and secure. 

AultmanNow offers your choice of trusted, U.S. board-certified providers 24/7/365. Telehealth provides options when you need to see a provider but are crunched for time; your provider's office is closed; if you are too sick to leave the house, traveling and forgot a prescription; and much more!





Here to Help You With Medicare

senior group of friends coupleWe are here to help you better understand Medicare. We provide education to those who are new to Medicare, considering switching plans, or interested in learning more.

Learn more about Medicare









Compare Plans and Enroll

senior couple looking at laptopWe make it easy to compare the different plans and benefits. You can start by exploring our website for easy-to-access information about our 4 different plan designs and find the plan that fits your budget and benefit needs.

If you have any questions about the plans, please give us a call and one of our local specialists will answer your questions and provide additional assistance in finding the plan for you. 

Compare plans or learn about your enrollment options

The top rating possible for 2024!

Get 5-star treatment with PrimeTime Health Plan. Every year Medicare rates plans, with the number of stars showing how well a plan performs based on member feedback and data from members, doctors, and hospitals. For 2024, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) awarded PrimeTime Health Plan a 5-star rating.

As CMS puts it, “More stars mean a better plan — for example, members may get better care and better, faster customer service.

2024 Star Rating icon 3 years in a row white box
Badge Medicare Advantage 2024 OHIO OL

U.S. News & World Report also analyzed plans in each state and rated PrimeTime one of the Best Insurance Companies for Medicare Advantage and prescription drug coverage in the entire nation for 2024.

PrimeTime Health Plan Basic MA – Only

Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
PrimeTime Health Plan Aultimate

Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
PrimeTime Health Plan Classic

Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
PrimeTime Health Plan Plus

Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details

Learn More from Our Local Specialists.

We are here to help you.

  • Call us at 330-363-7407 (TTY 711) from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., Monday through Friday. Talk to a local specialist or schedule a 1-on-1 meeting to discuss your options. 
  • Join us for a free informational webinar to ask questions and learn more about PrimeTime Health Plan's Medicare Advantage plans. 

Contact Us 

Trisha PrimeTime Health Plan Team Member
Debbie PrimeTime Health Plan Team Member
Karen PrimeTime Health Plan Team Member