We're here for
you.
Local care means you get top-rated Medicare Advantage service.

Better care because we're right here.

PrimeTime Health Plan is your locally owned Medicare Advantage alternative.

We exist to help YOU. You are the center of everything we do — today and every day over the past 25 years. When you call PrimeTime, you talk with a real person who’s your neighbor who’ll give you the time and attention you need.

We know this area; we know your providers like physicians and specialists; and we know how to work with them on your behalf. 90% of PrimeTime members stay PrimeTime members, for our superior customer service and integrated care coordination.

The top rating possible for 2022!

Get 5-star treatment with PrimeTime Health Plan. Every year Medicare rates plans, with the number of stars showing how well a plan performs based on member feedback and data from members, doctors and hospitals. For 2022, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) awarded PrimeTime Health Plan a 5-star rating.

As CMS puts it, “More stars mean a better plan — for example, members may get better care and better, faster customer service.



Medicare Advantage
– Plans
Rating
Stay healthy, screening tests vaccines
Managing chronic conditions
Member experience with the health plan
Member complaints and changes in the health plan's performance
Customer service
Medicare Advantage
– Drug Benefits
Rating
Customer service
Member complaints and changes in the drug plan's performance
Member experience with the drug plan
Drug safety and accuracy of drug pricing
Star Rating icon
Badge Medicare Advantage 2022 OHIO
U.S. News & World Report also analyzed plans in each state and rated PrimeTime one of the Best Insurance Companies for Medicare Advantage and prescription drug coverage in the entire nation for 2022.

With four plans, you have plenty of choices!

2022 Plan Overview and Comparison

PrimeTime Health Plan has a number of plan designs from which to choose. Our number one goal is to provide you with an affordable health plan designed to enhance your Medicare coverage.
Basic MA Only
(HMO-POS)

$0
Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
Aultimate
(HMO-POS)

$0
Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
Classic
(HMO-POS)

$39
Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
Plus
(HMO-POS)

$89
Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details

With four plans, you have plenty of choices!

2023 Plan Overview and Comparison

PrimeTime Health Plan has a number of plan designs from which to choose. Our number one goal is to provide you with an affordable health plan designed to enhance your Medicare coverage.
Basic MA Only
(HMO-POS)

$0
Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
Aultimate
(HMO-POS)

$0
Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
Classic
(HMO-POS)

$39
Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details
Plus
(HMO-POS)

$89
Monthly Premium
View More Plan Details

Contact one of our friendly representatives.

We are here to help you.

Call one of our friendly representatives or click the button below to complete our contact us form. You can also check out our upcoming live webinars or on-demand archived webinars for more information.

Contact Us 

Trisha Witts PrimeTime Health Plan Team Member
Trisha Witts
330-363-2046
Debbie Banal PrimeTime Health Plan Team Member
Debbie Banal
330-363-2006
Karen Krantz PrimeTime Health Plan Team Member
Karen Krantz
330-363-2020